DAILY TELEGRAPH: Michael Thorn: Lockout laws are keeping Sydney safe

Feb 7, 2017

Do we really want to roll the dice and risk all we have achieved? Sydney’s lockout laws have only been in place for two years and rates of violence and hospital emergency department ­presentations are down.

The action of the O’Farrell government in February 2014 achieved what health and law enforcement experts promised. Yet, here we are two years later talking about abandoning these lifesaving measures. What have we accomplished?

The lives of those who live and visit Kings Cross have been transformed. Police, diverted to act as taxpayer-funded crowd controllers for pub and clubs, can return to fighting crime.

St Vincent’s Hospital emergency department doctors can focus less on the bloody aftermath of alcohol-­fuelled street violence, and instead on other patients in need.

The late night phone calls to the families of teenagers suffering life-threatening injuries have stopped. And taxpayers have been ­relieved of some of the financial burden of managing the gross oversupply of alcohol in Kings Cross and Sydney’s CBD. Christine Foster’s view, (‘Sydney’s been locked out too long’, Daily Telegraph, (2/2/17) is typical of those calling for the cancellation of the massively successful lockout laws.

A flawed argument that suggests just because the crisis seems to have passed we can now relax these modest restrictions. Let’s apply this misplaced logic to other areas of community risk.

There hasn’t been an Australia airline hijacking in years; let’s discontinue security checks at airports, perhaps even allow people to carry firearms again. There are fewer road crashes; let’s relax the allowable blood alcohol limit to 0.08, maybe even axe it.

None of these things will happen because governments understand the risks of removing these safeguards and the importance of acting in the public interest. Governments’ role is to ­protect the community. The problem with the hectoring of the opponents of Sydney’s modest restrictions on ­alcohol supply is their refusal to ­accept, or even understand, this notion of the public interest. Foster, the Keep Sydney Open crowd and bar owners seem to think we can have it all — late trading and no alcohol harm.

The evidence of medical experts shows the longer the hours of trading, the more alcohol harm. The lesson from Sydney’s world-leading lockout laws is that alcohol harm has been ­reduced. The smart thing to do is to apply what we have learned more widely. As we have done with road safety, disease control and terrorism.

Michael Thorn is Chief Executive of the Foundation for Alcohol Research and Education (FARE)

Originally published in The Daily Telegraph

SMH: Changes to the liquor laws are no gift to NSW

Dec 16, 2016

With Christmas fast approaching, the Baird government is hell bent on its image makeover. Think less the Grinch that tried to euthanise the greyhound industry, destroy local councils and shut down an entire city, and more the loveable Santa determined to win your affection and in the longer term your vote. Read more.

GQ INC: Barry O’Farrell Breaks Silence On Sydney Lockout Laws

Dec 5, 2016

The former NSW Premier, and architect of Sydney’s ‘lockout laws’, opens up to GQ about the ongoing issues in the Harbour city.

Given the anti-Baird sentiment blanketing Sydney, many have forgotten that it was, in fact, the NSW premier’s predecessor, Barry O’Farrell, who crafted the lockout laws.

Read more.

SMH: Majority oppose plan to extend NSW bottle shop opening hours: poll

Dec 5, 2016

Public attitudes towards extending opening hours for bottle shops in NSW are split along generational lines with the majority of young people supportive but over half of the wider community opposed.

Read more. 

No evidence Star assaults under-reported SMH Rachel Olding and Sean Nicholls

Nov 24, 2016

Reported in the Sydney Morning Herald:

A study examining claims that The Star casino has been hiding assaults from the authorities has found no evidence of underreporting after the lockout and last drinks laws were introduced.

The NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research re-examined all 278 assaults at The Star since 2012 after leaked documents revealed last month that the casino had not reported about 67 per cent of violent incidents to the police.

The revelations raised the possibility that the Pyrmont casino, which sits just outside the lockout law zone and is therefore exempt from the 2014 reforms, was deliberately hiding assaults. However, BOCSAR director Don Weatherburn said their analysis, to be released on Thursday, does not support this.

The bureau classified the 278 assault reports according to who made the initial report to police. Researchers then compared the proportion of reports made by staff over time.

The study found that the proportion of assaults reported by staff had actually increased from 56.5 per cent in the two years before the lockout laws were introduced to 60 per cent in the two years after.

It follows previous BOCSAR reports that have shown a small increase in overall assaults at The Star since the lockout reforms.

‘‘No one expects every minor bump and scuffle to end up in a police assault report but we would have been concerned if the proportion of assault incidents reported to police by staff at The Star had declined,’’ Dr Weatherburn said.

‘‘As it is we remain of the view that the growth in assaults at The Star since the lockout has up to this point been fairly small.’’

The leaked documents, prepared by the NSW liquor and gaming regulator, said 75 of the 111 violent incidents between March and August did not result in police attendance.

Read original story here.

FARE’s 2016 Federal Election Alcohol Policy Scorecard

Jun 29, 2016

A majority (78 per cent) of Australians think we have a problem with alcohol and believe more needs to be done to address alcohol’s harm.

So where do the major parties stand on alcohol policy measures this election? Click here to find out.

Click here to find out.

Media release: Evidence shows, once again, alcohol laws are working

Jun 8, 2016

Statistics released by the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics Research (BOSCAR) are unequivocal evidence that the current suite of alcohol measures are working to reduce violence, emergency workers said today.

Last Drinks coalition spokesperson and President of the Police Association of NSW said the recent BOSCAR statistics, reported on today, which shows a huge decreases in assault rates in both the Kings Cross Precinct and the Sydney CBD Entertainment Precinct is further proof that the NSW Government must leave the current measures in place in the greater Sydney CBD area – and actually extend the successful measures to other areas of the state.

“Report after report backs up what emergency service workers on the ground are saying – there is far less violence on our streets now than there was prior to the alcohol laws being introduced,” Mr Weber said.

“In Kings Cross alone we’ve got a 59.2 per cent decrease between 6pm and 1.30am and a 93.9 per cent decrease between 3am and 6am. Those are staggering statistics and proof that the suite of measures are working.

“You’ve got to look at the whole picture, and the picture tells the very clear story that assault rates haven’t just dropped since the suite of alcohol measures were introduced, they’ve plummeted.

“Those opposed to the alcohol measures will do everything they can to skew the figures, but the facts do not lie – there’s been a huge reduction in assaults. Fewer innocent people are falling victim to alcohol-fuelled violence as a result of this suite of measures.

“We know the critics will try to say that the lock-outs aren’t working, that foot traffic in Kings Cross on Saturday nights and that the measures are harming our nightlife, but nothing could be further from the truth. All the evidence disputes the critics’ claims and backs up the fact that the current suite of measures are working to reduce violence.

“We don’t just want to see the current measures remain in place in areas like Kings Cross, we want to see them rolled out to other areas across the state too. Everyone deserves to know they can go out at night safely, regardless of where they live.”

The Last Drinks coalition represents NSW emergency service workers and includes doctors, police, nurses and paramedics.

Download the media release here.


Media release: All evidence shows current alcohol laws are saving lives

Jun 2, 2016

The Last Drinks coalition supports an evidence-based approach to dealing with the scourge of alcohol-fuelled violence, and all of the evidence points to the fact that the current measures in place in the greater Sydney area are working.

Last Drinks coalition spokesperson and President of the Police Association of NSW, Scott Weber, said that since the current suite of measures were introduced in the greater Sydney area, we’ve seen a 45 per cent decrease in late night assaults in the Kings Cross area.

“You can’t argue with the facts. Since the current suite of measures were introduced we’ve seen a huge decrease in the number of innocent people falling victim to alcohol-fuelled violence,” Mr Weber said.

“The Last Drinks coalition has always supported an evidence-based approach to dealing with alcohol-fuelled violence and all the available evidence shows, without a shadow of a doubt, that the current suite of measures is working.

“Since a suite of measures were introduced in Newcastle in 2008, there’s been a huge decrease in alcohol-fuelled violence and now we’re seeing that success mirrored in Sydney.

“Emergency service workers have certainly noticed the significant safety improvements we’ve enjoyed since alcohol measures were introduced in the greater Sydney CBD area. We’re confident the current review of the alcohol laws in Sydney will look at all the evidence and ensure that the successful measures remain in place.”

The Last Drinks coalition represents NSW emergency service workers and includes doctors, police, nurses and paramedics.

Click here to download the statement


Sydney-Style Lockout Laws To Go National?

Jun 1, 2016

The strict Sydney-style alcohol laws and pub lockouts could be introduced across the entire country if the powerful group behind some of Australia’s biggest hospitals gets its way.

St Vincent’s Health Australia, which manages the Sydney and Melbourne St Vincent’s hospitals, launched its pre-election calls to the major political parties on Wednesday. The health provider has called on the Coalition, Labor and the Greens to commit to reducing alcohol-related harm by 20 percent within 10 years, with a suite of policy ideas to reach that goal.

Read more

Annual alcohol poll 2016: Attitudes and behaviours

May 18, 2016

Each year the Foundation for Alcohol Research and Education’s (FARE) national alcohol poll provides valuable trend data and insights into community perspectives on alcohol. See the 2016 poll here.